Friday, February 4, 2022

How Can a Christian's Faith be "Dead"?

I recently heard a preacher on the radio say that the word "dead" in James 2:14-26 means "non-existent".  But is a dead tree non-existent? Or to use the analogy that James uses, we can ask: Is "the body without the spirit" (v. 26) non-existent? It's true that it is dead (separated from its soul and spirit), but the body is not non-existent! Do we bury non-existent bodies? Was the dead body of our Lord Jesus Christ non-existent? To say that it was is to deny a cardinal doctrine of the Christian faith! And yet this is the reasoning of some proponents of "Lordship Salvation" in regards to faith! They say that dead faith is "non-existent" faith. Or they say that dead faith is "a mere profession of faith." But that's not what James is saying. Rather, he's saying that "dead" faith is "by itself" (v. 17).[1] The faith is dead in the sense that it is "without works" (Ja. 2:20). In other words, the faith is there but it's not doing anything; it is separated from good works.[2] In the context of the Christian life (which is exactly what James is talking about in context), a "dead" faith cannot save a Christian brother or sister from a useless life (see Ja. 2:14). That's what James is talking about; not salvation from hell, but being saved from a dormant and inactive Christian life! So the faith that James is talking about is existent, but it's not useful.


ENDNOTES:

[1] See Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, s.v. nekros, definition 2b, "universally, destitute of force or power, inactive, inoperative: ... πίστις, James 2:17, 20..., 26" (p. 424). Commenting on James 2:17, Dr. Ralph "Yankee" Arnold affirms: "Dead does not mean unsaved or condemned. How can faith be dead? Dead is the Greek word nekros which means USELESS or BARREN. A dead battery in a car is a useless battery! It still exists, but it does not work, it is useless. Faith without works is useless [in regards to helping others]! 'I know you are starving, brother, but have faith in God. He will help you!' There you have at home all the food they need. Your faith is useless; it hasn't helped those who were starving!" (Yankee Arnold, The Gospel Driven Man, p. 142, capital letters his, brackets added.) Dr. Thomas L. Constable similarly states: "'Dead' [in James 2:17] does not mean non-existent but inactive, no longer vital, dormant, useless (cf. v. 14). This is a very important point." (Constable, Notes on James, comment on James 2:17.)

[2] In the Bible, death speaks of separation. The dead faith in James 2:17 is "by itself," separated from present good works (cf. Rev. 3:1-2). It is the old Russellite error (the present-day Jehovah's Witnesses cult) to say that death means absolute non-existence. It does not. And neither does "dead" faith mean non-existent faith. That is cult-like thinking and contrary to biblical truth. What the Bible teaches is that dead faith is "by itself" (Ja. 2:17), very much in existence but separated from good works.

1 comment:

  1. This blog post highlights the error of the Calvinistic interpretation of James 2:14-26. For more information see my article titled: "A Free Grace Response to John Piper on James 2:14-26" (FGFS, June 27, 2023).

    ReplyDelete

Please read before commenting: I use this comments section to add research updates and additional notes, serving as an addendum to the main post. To keep this space focused and organized, please send any comments you may have via the "Contact Me" form on my blog. Thank you!